When students have used mobile phones as part of their lives, We should ban it or take advantage of it?

I agree with the statement proposed by Jill and Tarina: Smartphone is one of the drivers distracting students from concentrating on their learning in the classroom. But I personally believe that this is not a compelling reason that smartphones should be banned in the classroom. This is primarily because Regardless of whether there is a ban, students will still use mobile phones to study outside the school and continue to use mobile phones in their future workplace. If a Smartphone can make work, communication, and information transmission more efficient, why is it impossible to use it in the classroom?

We have seen many shreds of evidence that smart devices have enhanced students’ learning process. For instance, If a student doesn’t understand a term or concept, the student can search the knowledge instantly. Apps like Google or Microsoft translator can reduce the language barriers for those new immigrant students. As Melinda pointed out:

” For a newcomer life without being fluent in the respective country’s language can be very stressful and having access to a cell phone could help ease this”.

Most importantly, social media, like Twitter provides students with more interactive space to communicate with their teachers and peers, this is an especially effective way to engage those introverted students with classroom discussion. For me, the nature of distraction does not come from the phone itself but the improper use of the mobile phone. Educators must better understand the design of learning scenarios that genuinely exploit the unique pedagogical possibilities of mobile technologies instead of replicating existing behavior patterns.

On the other hand, encouraging smartphone use in the classroom is a way of improving students’ “cell phone etiquette” as it is suggested by Brad. Most children are spending a lot of time online in or beyond school. A poor mastery in digital etiquette is likely to exacerbate social issues improper phone use create. Considering the fact that most parents grew up without relevant education, they may feel helpless when facing such a tricky issue. Therefore, it is important for teachers in their classrooms to teach our children how to behave and treat others online. Failure to do so may result in children abusing technology, harassing others and even putting them at risk of cyberbullying.
Although smartphones can present some risks, it’s important to understand what the benefits are to give your child the guidance they need to make the best out of their smart devices.


4 thoughts on “When students have used mobile phones as part of their lives, We should ban it or take advantage of it?

  1. Great perspective Altan! I agree. I am also finding that we need to teach students more and more how to treat people in real life. I think these can go hand in hand. I feel there are too many positives to completely ban cellphones. This year especially for me I relied heavily on Google Translate to build relationships with my students. I could not have done that without my cell phone or letting my students use theirs. I too agree with Brad about online etiquette. I feel that Digital Citizenship needs to be included in our curriculums because technology is not going away… with a ban or not! Thanks for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great post. I too have found a wealth of very important ways to integrate cell phones into the classroom such as using Remind to communicate more effectively with students. The translate feature has been essential to working with EAL students. Without a cell phone those communication and relationship buiLding opportunities would be almost impossible. It is a struggle at times when kids don’t use this powerful tool properly but instead of banning need to help with self regulation because I agree with you that these devices are a part of their future. Thanks for your thoughts.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Altan, great post! I totally agree with your position of needing solid procedures, expectations and boundaries about the use (and therefore limiting misuse) in the classroom. Melinda’s point also struck me as the cell phone can be a distraction, but it can also be a lifeline for all students, but especially for EAL students. The phone provides a way students can express themselves, take away some of the burden that comes with wanting to communicate but not sure how, and can give a much needed break from being fully immersed in a language they are not fluent in. This conversation shows yet another way that technology can aid students in feeling confident and comfortable in their learning environment.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Great post! It is great to know that through the use of the translator on cell phones today, people who speak different languages can communicate more easily. I definitely think that your personal experience supports the use of cell phones in the classroom. Thank you for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s